In instances where police arrested people watching porn at late-night parties, courts have quashed the FIR, holding that watching porn within a private space is no offe-nce under Indian laws. Courts have asserted the same about keeping porn content on phones, laptops or in CD form. One such judgment, delivered by the Rajasthan High Court, related to a case where police had raided a house and arres-ted four persons, including a woman, for watch-ing ‘obscene’ films on television. The court held that if the ‘obscene’ object is ins-ide a house and not for sale, hire, public exhibition or circulation, the accused can’t be charged under Section 292 of the IPC.

ALSO READ: Porn Again! The Land Of Kamasutra Is Now A Digital Porn Hub

National Crime Records Bureau data confirms the pattern. In 2019, 1,158 FIRs were filed for publishing or transmitting sexually explicit material—banned under sections 67A/67B of the Information and Technology Act. This works out to a ratio of around two persons per 10 lakh population. Of these cases, 249 were disposed of and nobody was convicted. Only 108 cases were registered in 2019 under sections 292, 293 and 294 of the IPC, which ban the sale of ‘obs-cene objects’. Their status hasn’t been rep-orted. Under the Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986, only 23 cases were reported in 2019-—18 were sent for trial; 12 resulted in acquittals; the rest remain pending; zero convictions. “There were 557 pending cases too and we got only seven convictions in them. Many are still under litigation,” says a police -officer.

ALSO READ: There Are Over 2,000 Porn Sites On Google, Why No Action Against Them, Asks Gehana Vasisth

One of the reasons why conviction is difficult is that no law deals directly with porn, says Nishant K. Srivastava, founder and managing partner, Actus Legal Associates & Advocates. “Take the Raj Kundra case. The allegations of involvement in ‘production’ and ‘publishing’ of porn as a ‘key conspirator’ are grave ones, yet it will be difficult to get a final conviction for many legal and technical reasons.” Not the least of them the fact that the law approaches various facets in a segmented fashion, via a -confusing welter of laws.

A conjoined reading of relevant sections of these laws makes one thing clear: they largely criminalise “production”, “publication”, “transmission” and “sale” of “obscene material”. “Production” is covered only indirectly, by the Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act. Another confusing aspect is the territorial application of Indian laws. For instance, Section 75 of the IT Act says prosecuting agencies may also implicate persons who committed any off-ence outside India, irrespective of their nationality. Other laws, however, have no universal jurisdiction. “If I am making a porn film, say, in the US, I will be tried according to US laws, if there are any. However, if I upload it on a website from there, even if US laws allow me to do so, I’ll be prosecuted in India,” says Srivastava.

ALSO READ: Teen Kanya? No, There Are Many More Nancy Bhabis Riding the Wild Side

Indore-based lawyer Kamlesh Vasvani, who filed the first PIL on the matter in the Supreme Court in 2013, says India needs a separate law that defines pornography and deals with all its aspects. His petition, which is still pending, raises the issue of porn content being accessible to minors. “Thousands of such sites are accessible, but the government is sleeping,” says Vasvani. “Income from internet and mobile users runs into billions of rupees every day. This establishes the connivance, conspiracy and malafide intentions of the government. I have also demanded an exhaustive anti-pornography law along with a nat-ional policy to tackle porn addiction.”

“The immediate solution is banning all porn sites so that their accessibility to -children can be stopped,” says Supreme Court lawyer D.K. Garg.

(This appeared in the print edition as "Sliding Through The Seams")

ALSO READ

Desi Divas: Know The Top Indian Porn Stars

Yes, But No! Watching Porn Is Individual Choice, Not Crime Against Women

Porn Out Of Purdah: Yes, Women Do Watch Porn, But....

‘Yes, I Watch Porn. There’s Nothing Wrong In It.’

Erotica Is Not Porn And Indians Still Don’t Know The Difference